A Famous Trick-or-Treat Experiment

With Halloween just two days away, I’m armed (with candy!) and ready. This preparation has caused me to think about the behavior of kids on Halloween, and I came across an interesting research study from the 1970s. Researchers set up an experiment (designed by professor of psychology Edward Diener) in Seattle with 1352 unsuspecting Halloween trick-or-treaters. At several participating houses, a bowl of candy (and at some houses, a bowl with nickels and pennies) was placed on a table just inside the front door. When trick-or-treaters knocked on the door, the researcher would invite the kids in and instruct them to take one piece of candy from the bowl. At some houses, the kids were asked their names and addresses; at others they were not. In other words, some of the kids were anonymous, particularly behind their costumes and masks; some were not. Then the researcher would excuse himself/herself and leave the area; however, s/he would watch through a peephole (yes, a peephole!) to see what happened. Here are the results; the numbers are percentages of kids who took more than one piece of candy (and in some cases, coins).

  • One child, not anonymous: 7.5%
  • A group of children, not anonymous: 20.8%
  • One child, anonymous: 21.4%
  • A group of children, anonymous: 57.7%

The differences between those kids who were asked for their names and addresses and those who were not asked are clearly very significant, whether it was one child or a group of children. Generally speaking, these differences are probably not surprising to most people; however, the magnitude of these differences might be. In terms of being anonymous or not, regardless of whether it was one child or a group, the rate of stealing (the researchers’ words, not mine) tripled. In terms of a single child vs. a group of children, the rate of stealing also tripled, regardless of anonymity. The researchers explained both kinds of differences in terms of deindividuation, a fancy word meaning a person has experienced a degree of loss of identity. And along with this, a loss of a feeling of responsibility. If you’re a child alone, and nobody knows who you are, you are much more likely to steal than if you are known. Similarly, if you’re a part of a group, you are more likely to steal because “everyone else is doing it”–especially if you’re anonymous. In both cases, a child feels less responsible–especially when hidden behind a mask!

One further finding from this experiment that I found the most fascinating is this: in a few cases, the experimenter told the smallest child in a group, “I will hold you responsible if any extra pieces of candy are missing.” The percentage of stealing children jumped to 80%! The researchers explained this in terms of a scapegoat; one child was regarded as responsible for the transgressions of the group–and again, that was the smallest child. I think that last percentage would have been much lower if the researcher had held the biggest child responsible.

Not surprisingly, these findings transfer to adults as well. Think about France, for example. Protests had been going on for about a month before escalating into violent riots (still ongoing) 12 days ago. Think also about the riots in several cities across the U.S. in the summer of 2020, following the death of George Floyd. It’s also interesting when you consider that most of the rioters (then and now) have been wearing masks, somewhat akin to kids wearing masks on Halloween night.

A couple of years ago, one of the brothers from my church put a bowl of candy outside his front door with a sign that said something like, “Enjoy your Halloween, and please take ONE piece of candy to leave some for others.” You can probably guess what happened: he reported later that the bowl went from very full to very empty in a very short period of time! He noticed on video (not through a peephole!) that kids grabbed handfuls of candy and ran. In a similar vein, when my kids were little (25+ years ago) and I took them out trick-or-treating, I noticed an empty bowl outside someone’s house more than once early in the evening.

Over the last few years, “trunk-or-treating” has become increasingly popular in my city. In fact, some brothers and sisters are holding such an event this year at my church; there will also be a “carnival,” including games. My wife and I will divide and conquer; she’ll be at church, while I’ll be at home handing out candy (yes, one per trick-or-treater), each with a message. My family has been attaching messages to our Halloween candy for many years. This year’s is pretty simple: “Taste and see that the Lord is good.” — Psalm 34:8 (the Bible) The little kids don’t care about the message, but the teens sometimes read it even before going to the next house.

Whether or not, and how, you choose to participate in Halloween, may your neighborhood be a peaceful but fun area on Halloween night! And don’t forget about time change this weekend!

10 thoughts on “A Famous Trick-or-Treat Experiment”

  1. Keith, just about all the Chinese-American pastors that I’ve come into contact with since the 1980s and 1990s have believed that Christians should not celebrate Halloween in any form. I believe this might be a reaction against traditional Chinese folk religion, which worships ancestors and idols. I know, however, that dressing children in costumes and going trick-or-treating is very popular among Chinese-Americans, even among some evangelical Christian families. On another matter, I like Arizona and Hawaii, which use standard time all year round. I don’t really care whether standard time or daylight savings time is used, but I just don’t like setting the clock every spring and fall.

    1. Tony, what you wrote about Chinese-American pastors doesn’t surprise me. It also doesn’t surprise me that attitudes toward Halloween are changing among some younger Chinese Christian families; I’ve seen it in my own church. I appreciate the push toward trying to redeem Halloween; as I mentioned in my post, my family and I have been attaching Bible-based messages to our candy for many years, and my church is hosting a “trunk-or-treat” tomorrow night, including the Gospel message.

      Regarding daylight saving time and standard time: switching from one to the other doesn’t bother me much anymore, but when our kids were little, I didn’t like it. In the fall, they would wake up too early the next morning, and in the spring, they would be too tired!

    1. Thank you, Brother. Yes, I was fascinated, too, especially by the “scapegoat.” As you said, the stats show our sinful nature.

      By the way, thanks for posting your lists of responses to the Skeptic; there’s a young brother at my church who is excited to have them! I know that he will read some of them, although he may not respond with comments.

Leave a Reply